Motion video skill: what to approve
Updated Tue Nov 17, 11:58 PM. Tap ur pick on each one, then Copy and paste it into the Slack thread.
Decisions
Which skill ships
Short skill in the exact graphics format (Workflow, Brand, References, Output, Rendering, Rules) vs the full 417-line one
My pick: Short, if it holds up on the final test with the rules below. Final side by sides land on this page
Results still coming in
One card held too long
Large: 22 of 33 videos across 9 brands. The full skill is the worst at it (7 of 8)
No card, number or screen sits unchanged for more than about 2 seconds. If a beat needs longer, bring something new in.
My pick: Add
UI cut off at the frame edge
Large: 11 of 33 videos across 8 brands, both skills. So not just Rippling
Every product screen or card sits fully inside the frame with a margin, unless it is a full-bleed background. No edge cuts through a row, word or widget.
My pick: Add
UI text too small on a phone
Large: 16 of 33 videos across 8 brands, both skills
Show only the few lines of UI that matter and zoom in so UI text is readable on a phone. Never shrink a full screenshot to fit.
My pick: Add
Blank or empty frames
Large: 9 of 33 videos across 7 brands, mostly the short skill (8 of 25). It came in with the fix for cards held too long, so these two go in together
No frame is ever empty: the next scene comes in before the last one leaves, and frame 0 already has content.
My pick: Add, together with 2
Count-up stops on an in-between number
Medium: 6 of 33 videos, 3 brands. This is behind the Linear 49.5K instead of 50,000
Counters finish in about a second and hold the exact sourced number.
My pick: Add, it is one line
Small stuff: wrong brand, wobble, fact errors
Each showed up in 1 to 3 videos only, and the skill already has rules for them
My pick: No new rules
Small problem or bigger problem?
Fable 5.2 checked all 33 different test videos from tonight (8 full skill, 25 short, 10 brands). Large = 3+ brands and 25%+ of videos.
| Issue | Videos | Brands | Full | Short | Scope |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| One card held too long | 22 of 33 | Clay, Imagine AI, Linear, Notion, Ramp, Rippling, Stripe, Supabase, Vercel | 88% | 60% | large |
| UI text too small on a phone | 16 of 33 | Clay, Figma, Imagine AI, Linear, Ramp, Rippling, Supabase, Vercel | 50% | 48% | large |
| UI cut off at the frame edge | 11 of 33 | Clay, Figma, Linear, Ramp, Rippling, Stripe, Supabase, Vercel | 50% | 28% | large |
| Blank or empty frames | 9 of 33 | Clay, Figma, Imagine AI, Linear, Ramp, Rippling, Supabase | 13% | 32% | large |
| Count-up stops on an in-between number | 6 of 33 | Clay, Linear, Ramp | 13% | 20% | medium |
| Under 3 different scenes | 4 of 33 | Clay, Linear, Ramp | 13% | 12% | medium |
| Wrong brand | 3 of 33 | Clay, Supabase | 13% | 8% | small |
| Wrong number or claim | 2 of 33 | Linear | 13% | 4% | small |
| Wobble | 1 of 33 | Ramp | 0% | 4% | small |
Short vs full, side by side
What each part of the skill actually does
Each row = the short skill with that part removed. Keep = videos got worse without it.
| Part | Evidence | |
|---|---|---|
| Ablation running | ||
The skill file
Final short SKILL.md (coming)
Final short version not ready yet