Motion video skill: what to approve

Updated Tue Nov 17, 11:58 PM. Tap ur pick on each one, then Copy and paste it into the Slack thread.

417 linesFull skill now
103 linesGraphics skill
~110 targetShort skill

Decisions

1

Which skill ships

Short skill in the exact graphics format (Workflow, Brand, References, Output, Rendering, Rules) vs the full 417-line one

My pick: Short, if it holds up on the final test with the rules below. Final side by sides land on this page

Results still coming in

2

One card held too long

Large: 22 of 33 videos across 9 brands. The full skill is the worst at it (7 of 8)

No card, number or screen sits unchanged for more than about 2 seconds. If a beat needs longer, bring something new in.

My pick: Add

3

UI cut off at the frame edge

Large: 11 of 33 videos across 8 brands, both skills. So not just Rippling

Every product screen or card sits fully inside the frame with a margin, unless it is a full-bleed background. No edge cuts through a row, word or widget.

My pick: Add

4

UI text too small on a phone

Large: 16 of 33 videos across 8 brands, both skills

Show only the few lines of UI that matter and zoom in so UI text is readable on a phone. Never shrink a full screenshot to fit.

My pick: Add

5

Blank or empty frames

Large: 9 of 33 videos across 7 brands, mostly the short skill (8 of 25). It came in with the fix for cards held too long, so these two go in together

No frame is ever empty: the next scene comes in before the last one leaves, and frame 0 already has content.

My pick: Add, together with 2

6

Count-up stops on an in-between number

Medium: 6 of 33 videos, 3 brands. This is behind the Linear 49.5K instead of 50,000

Counters finish in about a second and hold the exact sourced number.

My pick: Add, it is one line

7

Small stuff: wrong brand, wobble, fact errors

Each showed up in 1 to 3 videos only, and the skill already has rules for them

My pick: No new rules

Small problem or bigger problem?

Fable 5.2 checked all 33 different test videos from tonight (8 full skill, 25 short, 10 brands). Large = 3+ brands and 25%+ of videos.

IssueVideosBrandsFullShortScope
One card held too long22 of 33Clay, Imagine AI, Linear, Notion, Ramp, Rippling, Stripe, Supabase, Vercel88%60%large
UI text too small on a phone16 of 33Clay, Figma, Imagine AI, Linear, Ramp, Rippling, Supabase, Vercel50%48%large
UI cut off at the frame edge11 of 33Clay, Figma, Linear, Ramp, Rippling, Stripe, Supabase, Vercel50%28%large
Blank or empty frames9 of 33Clay, Figma, Imagine AI, Linear, Ramp, Rippling, Supabase13%32%large
Count-up stops on an in-between number6 of 33Clay, Linear, Ramp13%20%medium
Under 3 different scenes4 of 33Clay, Linear, Ramp13%12%medium
Wrong brand3 of 33Clay, Supabase13%8%small
Wrong number or claim2 of 33Linear13%4%small
Wobble1 of 33Ramp0%4%small

Short vs full, side by side

Rippling AI launchLeft = full skill, right = short (round 4)
Ramp dataLeft = full skill, right = short (round 4)
Supabase product UILeft = full skill, right = short (round 4)
Clay raiseLeft = full skill, right = short (round 4)
Linear kineticLeft = full skill, right = short (round 4)

What each part of the skill actually does

Each row = the short skill with that part removed. Keep = videos got worse without it.

PartEvidence
Ablation running

The skill file

Final short SKILL.md (coming)
Final short version not ready yet
Tap ur picks above